Fixed recoverable legal costs for clinical negligence claims under £25,000 – consultation begins

On Monday 30 January the Department of Health published its long-awaited consultation paper on introducing fixed recoverable costs for clinical negligence claims. These would be mandatory for all clinical negligence claims (i.e. applying to claims arising in the health service as well as in other/private treatment settings) valued between £1,000 and £25,000 and the consultation includes detailed costs figures.

Approximately 80% of all claims settled for damages against the NHS in England in 2015/16 fall within this range. It is also at these relatively lower levels of damages that the disproportionality of claimant legal costs appears at its greatest – the consultation reports that in these cases total claimant costs are more than double, 220%, the damages awarded. The consultation will close on 1 May 2017.

Continue reading

Mediation, costs, sanctions and reducing bills

Headlines about Bristow v Princess Alexandra Hospital tend to suggest that failure to mediate the costs aspects landed the defence with a huge costs sanction at detailed assessment.

In fact, the very first sentence of the brief costs judgment shows that the claimants lost over 43% at the assessment: “A bill was originally lodged for approximately £239,000 and the basic fact is that upon a detailed assessment this was reduced to £135,486.90.” Continue reading